Airbnb vs Other OTAs: A Side-by-Side Comparison

img Jason Astono | February 14, 2025

Online Travel Agencies (OTAs) have revolutionized how people book accommodations, offering convenience and a variety of options. Hello, I’m Jason, a Business Journalist at Bukit Vista and I will walk you among popular online travel agencies and their differences. Today, Airbnb has emerged as a leader, standing apart from traditional OTAs like Booking.com, Expedia, and Vrbo. This article provides a detailed side-by-side comparison of Airbnb and other OTAs, focusing on their key differences and why travelers and hosts might prefer one over the other.

online travel agencies

Market Dominance and User Base in Online Travel Agencies

online travel agencies
Feature Airbnb Booking.com, Expedia, Vrbo
Market Share Airbnb dominates with over 150 million active users worldwide and continues to grow exponentially since its launch in 2008. Booking.com and Expedia primarily focus on hotel bookings, with slower growth in alternative accommodations.
Listings Growth Airbnb leads with the highest number of unique listings globally, surpassing competitors by 2025. Vrbo has fewer listings (approximately one-third of Airbnb’s), while Booking.com focuses mainly on hotels.
Brand Recognition Airbnb is synonymous with short-term rentals and alternative stays, becoming a household name globally. Booking.com dominates in Europe for hotel bookings; Expedia is strong in the U.S.; Vrbo caters to niche vacation rentals.

Airbnb’s exponential growth and global reach make it the go-to platform for unique stays and short-term rentals. Its ability to cater to diverse markets, from urban cities to remote destinations, has solidified its position as the leader in alternative accommodations. As an online travel agency, Airbnb continuously innovates to meet traveler demands, reinforcing its dominance in the industry.

Accommodation Variety

online travel agencies
Feature Airbnb Booking.com, Expedia, Vrbo
Accommodation Types Airbnb focuses on unique stays: private homes, apartments, treehouses, tiny houses, boutique spaces. Booking.com primarily offers hotels and motels; Expedia has limited focus on vacation rentals or unique accommodations.
Target Audience Airbnb is ideal for travelers seeking local experiences, digital nomads, families, and groups. Hotels cater to business travelers or tourists seeking standardized stays; Vrbo targets family vacationers.
Customization Airbnb offers personalized stays with direct host interaction and tailored experiences. Hotels provide standardized services with minimal personalization or guest-host interaction.

 

Airbnb’s emphasis on unique accommodations and localized experiences appeals to travelers looking for something beyond traditional hotels. In contrast, other online travel agencies like Booking.com focus on standardized hotel rooms that, while convenient, often lack the charm and personalization that Airbnb offers. This focus on distinct, immersive stays gives Airbnb a competitive edge in the OTA market, attracting travelers who seek memorable and authentic experiences.

Guest Protections and Policies

Feature Airbnb (AirCover) Booking.com, Expedia, Vrbo
Guest Protections Airbnb’s comprehensive AirCover program includes booking guarantees, check-in support, and 24/7 safety assistance. Limited guest protections; policies vary by hotel or property manager.
Cancellation Policies Flexible policies set by individual Airbnb hosts; full refunds in case of cancellations or discrepancies. Often rigid cancellation policies tied to hotel chains or property managers’ terms.
Liability Coverage for Hosts $3 million damage protection and $1 million liability insurance for hosts under AirCover. Limited or no liability coverage for hosts; Vrbo offers basic protection but lacks flexibility.

Airbnb’s AirCover program provides unparalleled security for both guests and hosts, making it a safer choice compared to other online travel agencies that offer limited protections. AirCover includes booking guarantees, check-in support, and 24/7 safety assistance, ensuring that guests have help whenever needed. For hosts, AirCover offers protection against property damage and liability claims, giving them confidence to welcome travelers into their homes. These comprehensive protections set Airbnb apart from other OTAs, enhancing its reputation as a reliable and secure online travel agency.

Why Travelers Prefer Airbnb

Airbnb, one of the leading online travel agencies, provides unique stays that offer personalized experiences for travelers. With options ranging from private homes and boutique apartments to treehouses, guests can choose accommodations that suit their preferences. Staying in residential neighborhoods also allows visitors to immerse themselves in the local culture, providing a more authentic travel experience compared to traditional hotels.

As an online travel agency, Airbnb is particularly cost-effective for families, groups, or long-term travelers. Booking entire homes can save money compared to reserving multiple hotel rooms, and discounts for extended stays make Airbnb an attractive choice for digital nomads and remote workers. 

Additionally, online travel agencies like Airbnb offer flexibility and transparency with features such as flexible cancellation policies and upfront pricing, ensuring guests are aware of all costs. Enhanced safety measures under the AirCover program further provide peace of mind with booking guarantees, check-in support, and 24/7 safety assistance, reinforcing Airbnb’s position as a trusted online travel agency.

Ready to maximize your property's potential with expert Airbnb management?

Bukit Vista helps property owners enhance guest experiences, improve rankings, and increase bookings with personalized strategies and hands-on management. Join our community of successful hosts and let us handle everything—from optimizing your listing to ensuring top-notch guest satisfaction.

Take the First Step to Hassle-Free Property Management, Contact Us Today!

Bukit Vista is here to help you elevate your property and place you at the top 1%.

Compare listings

Compare
💬 Need help for partnership?